• March 27, 2024

Atal pension plan ‘coercive’, says Jairam, finance minister returns fire | India News – Times of India

Atal pension plan ‘coercive’, says Jairam, finance minister returns fire | India News – Times of India
Share


NEW DELHI: In a faceoff on micro-blogging platform X, finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman and Congress MP Jairam Ramesh traded charges over the Atal Pension Yojana, with govt dismissing charges of coercion and enrollment of beneficiaries without their consent.
It all began on Tuesday morning with Ramesh citing a study by the Indian Council of Social Science Research to suggest that nearly a third of the beneficiaries of the scheme launched by the Modi govt were enrolled by bankers without their “explicit permission” so that targets could be met.Describing it as a poorly-designed scheme, he also said that returns were not attractive.
Sitharaman shot back accusing Ramesh of “using verbal sophistry to hide facts” and of “being malicious or ignorant of the basic tenets of designing a good pension scheme”. She said the scheme is designed to “automatically continue premium payment unless the subscriber opts out” instead of annually opting in.
She said the scheme comes with a guaranteed return of 8% and the idea is to target the poor and lower middle class – a remark meant to counter the allegation that most APY beneficiaries were in the lowest income-bracket.
The head of Congress’s communication unit came back to argue that Sitharaman had “admitted” that APY was coercive and that the scheme guaranteed Rs 1,000 pension for a majority of subscribers, starting 2035.
“Keep in mind, a Rs 1,000 per month pension in 2035 is equivalent to just Rs 617 per month in 2024 prices (assuming a continuation of Modi-era inflation rates). This is the kind of erosion of value that makes APY a poorly-designed scheme,” he tweeted.
In the evening, FM responded, calling Ramesh a “spin doctor” and asserted that an account is only opened after obtaining explicit consent from the subscriber, with an exit scheme also in place. She said Ramesh’s allegations were based on “cherry-picked” data and cited the study’s finding to say that only 38 out of the 2,461 respondents, only 1.5% of the sample, have a “perception of (their) account being opened without consent”.
She said since inception, the scheme had given 9.1% return and argued that UPA’s Swavalambhan scheme for unorganised sector workers could get 35 lakh beneficiaries in four years, compared to APY’s 6.4 crore in nine years.




Source


Share

Related post

‘If people feel I can make a difference, I surely will’: Robert Vadra hints at political debut | India News – Times of India

‘If people feel I can make a difference,…

Share Robert Vadra celebrates his wife and Congress general secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra’s win NEW DELHI: Businessman and…
Govt selects 8 startups for support under quantum, cyber-physical systems missions | India News – Times of India

Govt selects 8 startups for support under quantum,…

Share Union science and technology minister Jitendra Singh along with NITI Aayog member V K Saraswat and representatives…
SC supersedes Calcatta HC on CBI probe, forms SIT: ‘Giving probes routinely to investigating agency burdens it, saps police morale’ | India News – Times of India

SC supersedes Calcatta HC on CBI probe, forms…

Share NEW DELHI: Supreme Court on Monday set up a three-member special investigation team to probe, under the…